3/4 – AJC – Immigrant labor – legal or illegal – offers a temptation to cheat | Jay Bookman

Immigrant labor – legal or illegal – offers a temptation to cheat | Jay Bookman

Two of the nation’s hottest political issues — the conservative drive to slash federal spending, and the controversy over illegal immigration — are playing out in the courtrooms and farms of Georgia.

In fact, they intersect in an interesting place, in the H2-A program that allows farmers to import temporary farm workers to do the hard labor that Americans supposedly won’t do. In debate at the Georgia Legislature over illegal immigration, an expanded H2-A program is mentioned often as a legal source of labor for Georgia agriculture, the state’s largest industry.

Under the H2-A program, thousands of workers are recruited from their home country — in most cases, Mexico — and are brought to the United States to do seasonal work. They are guaranteed a wage — currently $9.11 an hour — as well as room and board and travel expenses.

That’s a higher wage-and-benefit package than illegal immigrants can demand. Farmers participating in the H2-A program also have to put up with more paperwork and regulations than they would if they just paid illegal immigrants in cash. In fact, tougher H2-A rules implemented by the Obama administration have made the program less attractive to farmers, according to Charles Hall, executive director of the Georgia Fruit and Vegetable Growers Association.

Hall is also a critic of the role played by Legal Services Corporation, a nonprofit agency funded in part through federal dollars that offers legal representation to low-income clients who would otherwise not have access to the court system.

“Over the past ten years, the LSC have filed frivolous lawsuits against Georgia fruit and vegetable growers, particularly farmers involved with the H2-A guest worker program,” Hall said, lauding an attempt by House Republicans to slash funding for the agency by $88 million.

In fact, U.S. Rep. Lynn Westmoreland, R-Ga., wants to eliminate funding for the group altogether.

“The Legal Services Corporation does nothing more than abuse our legal system in an effort to take advantage of Georgia fruit and vegetable producers, as well as migrant farm workers,” Westmoreland said in a statement. “Their continual frivolous lawsuits and harassment of Georgia farmers only drive up the cost of business on an agriculture industry that is already suffering, increasing the price of food for consumers.”

We probably all agree that frivolous lawsuits are bad. However, Dawson Morton, a senior staff attorney for Georgia Legal Services, said he was surprised to hear his work described as frivolous. By his count, he and his small team have filed 29 cases in the last 10 years against Georgia farmers. In some cases, the suits allege that farmers have mistreated or cheated H2-A workers out of their wages. In roughly a third of the cases, the suits allege that farmers have brought in more compliant foreign workers while illegally refusing to hire American workers willing to do the jobs.

In 28 of those 29 cases, Morton says, he and his team have won financial judgments and settlements that total more than $2 million. That high batting average suggests that Westmoreland’s attempt to defund the LSC is driven not by the fact that it files frivolous lawsuits or even by an effort to save taxpayers’ money, but because so many of those lawsuits have a lot of merit.

(For the record, Hall explains Morton’s success rate by saying that farmers would rather settle cases than pay legal fees.)

In one recent case, Morton and his team won a settlement of $358,977 from a farmer who had retaliated against H2-A migrant workers for daring to complain about being cheated on their wages. Rather than rehire those workers, the farmer had turned to illegal immigrants. As part of the consent order settling the case, the farmer agreed to verify the legal status of all employees through the federal government’s E-Verify system.

According to Morton, he and his team have made use of E-Verify a condition of settling three or four cases so far. “However, that doesn’t mean they’re actually using it,” he says.

The economic incentives to break the rules — whether with H2-A workers or illegal immigrants — are simply that powerful.

– Jay Bookman


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: